Posted by
davecatbone on Friday, September 21, 2007 5:21:24 AM
There actually are some things John McCain says that are relevant. In
spite of the fact his campaign should fold up the tents for his stand
on illegal aliens if nothing else, he has pointed out one of the
biggest problems with Rudy Giuliani.
The SFGate reports:Republican presidential candidate John McCain
lobbed a thinly veiled attack at fellow rival Rudy Giuliani, describing
the former mayor's "devious" attempt with a lawsuit "to bankrupt our
great gun manufacturers."
"My friends, gun owners are not extremists;
you are the core of modern America," McCain said in the prepared
remarks. "The Second Amendment is unique in the world and at the core
of our constitutional freedoms. It guarantees an individual right to
keep and bear arms. To argue anything else is to reject the clear
meaning of our founding fathers.
For
his part, with a judge beginning to hear opening arguments in a lawsuit
many mayors including Rudy have brought against gun manufacturers,
Giuliani is going into the lion's den. CBS reports:
Republican presidential candidate Rudy Giuliani said Thursday that he
"hopes to clarify” his views on the right to bear arms when he speaks
to the National Rifle Association on Friday.
Rudy is going to attempt to do the tightrope walk, and convince gun owners he doesn't mean them harm. Good luck with that one.
On the Second Amendment, Giuliani has said
the right to bear arms applies to militias but also said recently that
it applies to individuals.
He described the NRA as "extremists" in a 1995 interview with
PBS' Charlie Rose: "The NRA, for some reason, I think goes way
overboard. It's almost what the extremists on the other side do. I
think the extremists of the left and the extremists of the right have
essentially the same tactic — the slippery slope theory. `If you give
one point, then your entire argument is going to fall apart,' and we
kind of get destroyed by that," Giuliani said.
His
stands on illegal immigration, abortion and gun control may sink Rudy's
ship. There seems to be not one single candidate on the board that can
appeal to conservatives. What is the GOP doing to itself? Anybody got
30 million bucks to spare for Newt's campaign?
UPDATE 12.30pm: Rudy's remarks from his NRA speech today:
He indicated that he would oppose new efforts to tighten national gun laws.
"I believe that law enforcement should focus on enforcing the laws
that exist on the books as opposed to passing new extensions of laws,"
he said. "A person's home is their castle. They have the right to
protect themselves in their own home."
Giulaini explained the lawsuit he initiated in 2000 against gun
manufacturers by saying that he was "excessive in everyway that I could
think of in order to reduce crime" but said that "intervening events"
like September 11th had caused his views to evolve. "I think that
lawsuit has gone in the direction that I don't agree it."